The OER Knowledge Cloud makes use of cookies. By continuing, you consent to this use. More information.
OER as online edutainment resources: A critical look at open content, branded content, and how both affect the OER movement
Moe, Rolin

PublishedJuly 2015
JournalLearning, Media and Technology
Volume 40, Issue 3, Pages 350 - 364

Despite a rise in awareness and production of open education resources (OER) over the past decade, mainstream media outlets continue to define open in economic terms of consumer cost and not in theoretical terms of remix or appropriation. This period in the open access debate has coincided with a proliferation of free-of-charge video content available on the internet, branded with institutional affiliation and labeled as educational or edutainment resources. Videos from organizations such as TED, and Upworthy have gained scholastic use and are being labeled as OER, despite a missive from their organizations to limit consumer use of the videos to viewing and sharing. Viewed instrumentally, the lack of remix utility for this edutainment creates only a slight distinction between their product and OER-as-defined. However, when viewed from a critical theory lens, the content-as-brand video edutainment phenomenon is strikingly different from the OER movement, and the lack of mainstream clarity on the delineation has created confusion in the OER movement, potentially a serious problem for the future of the OER movement as a social value rather than only a free tool. This paper utilizes a critical theory framework to identify the sociocultural, economic and political differences between traditional OER and institutionally derived video content. Building upon Jean-Francois Lyotard's criticism of grand narratives in the schema of knowledge, the paper begins with an historical literature review of edutainment in the guise of OER, and how the development and consumption of branded content strengthens a sociopolitical rendering of knowledge as a commodity rather than a ubiquitous public good. The paper then compares contemporary media coverage and cultural cache of OER content with that of branded edutainment content. Efforts to consolidate OER practitioners around a critical definition of OER, as well as opportunities to differentiate between OER and free-of-charge edutainment in the mainstream media, are important issues for further study.

Keywords commodification · critical theory · edutainment · knowledge · Lyotard · OER · online education

RightsCopyright © 2016 Informa UK Limited
Other informationLearning, Media and Technology
Export optionsBibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar

Viewed by 65 distinct readers


The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.

Click a star to be the first to rate this document


The phenomenal MOOC: Sociocultural effects of a Marginal Learning Model
Moe, Rolin; Veletsianos, George
Match: Moe, Rolin

Uptake of OER by staff in distance education in South Africa
de Hart, Kerry Lynn; Chetty, Yuraisha B.; Archer, Elizabeth
Open Educational Resources (OER) emerged within the context of open education which is typically characterized by the sharing of knowledge and resources and the exchange of ideas. Unisa as a mega open distance learning ...
Match: knowledge; OER

Open educational resources and teaching in the 21st century: Questions concerning authority
Ferreira, Giselle
As a source of materials for education the Web is, to a large extent, shifting ground. Open Educational Resources (OER) provided by Higher Education Institutions constitute, at least in principle, a reliable category of ...
Match: resources

Harnessing Open Educational Resources to the challenges of teacher education in Sub-Saharan Africa
Thakrar, Jayshree; Wolfenden, Freda; Zinn, Denise
The challenges to teacher educators in sub-Saharan Africa are acute. This paper describes how the Teacher Education in Sub-Saharan Africa (TESSA) consortium is working within institutional and national policy systems to ...
Match: resources

Opening up education: The collective advancement of education through open technology, open content, and open knowledge
Lane, Andy; Iiyoshi, Toru; Kumar, M. S. V.
Match: resources

From OER to MOO Cs: Critical perspectives on the historical mediation trajectories of open education
Alevizou, Giota
This article considers the intersections between digital and open education to explore how openness, as a value and currency, has conditioned the mediation trajectories of pedagogical knowledge domains and communicative ...
Match: commodification

Changing our (dis)course: A distinctive social justice aligned definition of Open Education
Lambert, Sarah
This paper investigates the degree to which recent digital Open Education literature is aligned to social justice principles, starting with the first UNESCO definition of Open Educational Resources (OER). A critical ...
Match: critical theory

Toward a critical approach for OER: A case study in removing the 'Big Five' from OER creation
Joseph, Kris; Guy, Julia; McNally, Michael B.
This paper examines the role of proprietary software in the production of open educational resources (OER). Using a single case study, the paper explores the implications of removing proprietary software from an OER ...
Match: critical theory

Awareness on Copyright among Students
Padil, Hazlina Mohd; Azmi, Amylia Fuziana; Ahmad, Nor Laila; Shariffuddin, Norashikin; et al.
Copyright refers to the rights of the authors over their literary and artistic works. This legal term protects the owner of their copyrighted work from being infringed by others. Infringement happens when the work of ...
Match: knowledge

Academic knowledge mobilisation to promote cultural change towards openness in education
Burgos Aguilar, José Vladimir; Montoya, Maria Soledad Ramírez; McGreal, Rory; Kinuthia, Wanjira; Marshall, Stewart
Match: knowledge