Are We Asking Too Much of OER? A Conversation on OER from OE Global 2023
Published | 28 October 2024 |
Journal | The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning Volume 25, Issue 4, Pages 201-214 |
Country | Canada, North America |
ABSTRACT
This paper examines the pervasive discourse of disruption in OER literature by recounting a facilitated conversation hosted at the 2023 Open Education Global conference held in Edmonton, Alberta. This dialogue used Bacchi’s “what is the problem represented to be” (WPR) approach to structure the conversation in four movements. The first movement problematized the concept of OER by discussing the educational challenges OER supposedly addresses, such as the high cost of textbooks. The second movement considered the genealogy, historical development, and philosophical underpinnings of OER. The third movement accounted for the disruptors within the OER movement, exploring what OER have disrupted and discussing if disruption is even a legitimate goal of OER. The fourth and final movement pivoted to examine resistors and forms of resistance to OER, including the protection of intellectual property rights, copyright concerns, and Marcuse’s idea of repressive tolerance. This single conversation generated a small but important piece of social intelligence within a much larger dialogue about open education, open pedagogy, and OER during a time of flux (characterized by intense politicization, the relentless progression of educational technology, the intensification of marketization, and the growing popularity of all-inclusive textbooks). This social intelligence can be used to guide the next transition phase for OER development. While the conversation does not offer tidy solutions or even clear recommendations, it does suggest that the next wave of OER practitioners would always do well to focus on the goals OER can achieve, not what they hope to disrupt. Keywords | open educational resources · OER · Carol Bacchi · disruption · textbooks |
Language | English |
ISSN | 1492-3831 |
Refereed | Yes |
Rights | CC BY |
DOI | 10.19173/irrodl.v25i4.7744 |
URL | https://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/7744 |
Export options | BibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar |
AVAILABLE FILES
Viewed by 72 distinct readers
CLOUD COMMUNITY REVIEWS
The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.
Click a star to be the first to rate this document
▶ POST A COMMENT
SIMILAR RECORDS
Investigating the perceptions, use, and impact of open textbooks: A survey of post-secondary students in British Columbia
Jhangiani, Rajiv; Jhangiani, Surita
Unrelenting increases in the price of college textbooks have prompted the development and adoption of open textbooks, educational resources that are openly licensed and available to students free of cost. Although ...
Match: textbooks; Canada; North America
Effects of open textbook adoption on teachers’ open practices
Mason, Stacie; Kimmons, Royce
The purpose of this qualitative study was to understand whether certain theoretical benefits that open educational resources (OER) might have on teacher practice were being realized by a group of secondary teachers ...
Match: OER; textbooks; North America
Academic Librarians Examination of University Students' and Faculty's Perceptions of Open Educational Resources
Fischer, Lane; Belikov, Olga; Ikahihifo, Tarah K.; Hilton III, John; et al.
A survey of 2,574 students and 1,157 faculty members across ten institutions of postsecondary education in the state of Utah was conducted by the Utah Academic Libraries Consortium. Survey items were created to ...
Match: open educational resources; OER; textbooks; North America
College textbooks made more accessible through Netflix-like subscription
Roddy, Kate
Through a new subscription service, students are given unlimited access to over 20,000 online resources.
Match: OER; textbooks; North America
Finding Free OER Textbooks Online: Untangling the Web
Walters, William H.
Although Open Educational Resources (OERs) can help reduce costs and maximize access to instructional materials, academics face significant problems in identifying good OER textbooks. This can be traced, in part, to the ...
Match: OER; textbooks; North America
Vers un plan d'action de l'OIF sur les ressources éducatives libres dans l'espace francophone
Organization Internationale de la Francophonie
Une vingtaine d’experts du Nord et du Sud se sont réunis du 4 au 7 février 2013 à Moncton (Canada-Nouveau Brunswick) pour l’élaboration d’un plan d’action de l’OIF en faveur du développement des ...
Match: open educational resources; OER; Canada; North America
Breaking Barriers: Understanding and Removing Barriers to OER Use
Carson, Brandon
While there are many benefits to the use of OER, such as cost savings for students, increased access to resources, and the ability for faculty to adapt the resources to meet their specific needs, new and experienced ...
Match: open educational resources; OER; Canada; North America
A place for policy: The role of policy in supporting open educational resources and practices at Ontario’s colleges and universities
Skidmore, James M.; Provida, Myrto
What can institutions of higher learning do structurally to improve the uptake of open educational resources and practices? That is the basic question guiding this report. Policy is a tool with which institutions ...
Match: open educational resources; OER; Canada; North America
Exploring the practices of educators using open educational resources (OER) in the British Columbia higher education system
Porter, David Alexander; McClaren, Milton; Xin, Cindy
This thesis details a study that investigated the role of open educational resources (OER) in the work of post-secondary educators in British Columbia. An aim of this study was to assess the current state of knowledge ...
Match: OER; Canada; North America
Open educational resources and global online learning
McGreal, Rory
This piece highlights how Open Educational Resources (OER) can help bridge the knowledge divide to achieve equity in education. The author discusses the different digital barriers set in place to prevent free access to ...
Match: open educational resources; OER; Canada; North America