The OER Knowledge Cloud makes use of cookies. By continuing, you consent to this use. More information.
Ascertaining the relevance of Open Educational Resources by integrating various quality indicators
Sanz, Javier · Dodero, Juan Manuel · Sánchez, Salvador

PublishedJuly 2011
JournalRevista de Universidad y Sociedad del Conocimiento (RUSC)
Volume 8, Issue 2, Pages 211-224

The aim of the open educational resource (OER) development movement is to provide free access to high quality educational materials in repositories. However, having access to a large amount of educational materials does not provide any assurance of their quality, and the mechanisms so far used to recommend educational resources have shown themselves to be lacking for a variety of reasons. Most evaluation systems are based on a costly manual inspection, which does not allow all materials to be evaluated. Moreover, it is often the case that other useful pieces of information are ignored, such as the use that users make of the materials, the evaluations that users perform on them and the metadata used to describe them. To try and improve this situation, this article presents the shortcomings of existing proposals and identifies every possible quality indicator that is able to provide the necessary information to enable materials to be recommended to users. By studying a significant set of materials contained in the MERLOT repository, the relationships among various, currently available quality indicators were analysed and numerous correlations among them were established. On the basis of that analysis, a measure of relevance is proposed, which integrates all existing quality indicators. Thus, the explicit evaluations made by users or experts, the descriptive information obtained from metadata and the data obtained from the use of the latter are employed in order to increase the reliability of recommendations by integrating various quality aspects. In addition, this measure is sustainable because it can be calculated automatically and does not require human intervention; this will allow all educational materials located in repositories to be rated.

Keywords e-learning · evaluation · MERLOT · OER quality · Open Educational Resources

URL eng
Export optionsBibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar

1031-2203-1-PB.pdf · 698.3KB31 downloads

Viewed by 58 distinct readers


The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.

Click a star to be the first to rate this document


Measuring the success of scaleable open online courses
Klobas, Jane E.
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to propose measures of online open course success for non-commercial institutional providers of massive open online courses (MOOCs) and other scaleable open online courses ...
Match: e-learning; evaluation

A barrier framework for open e-learning in public administrations
Stoffregen, Julia; Pawlowski, Jan M.; Pirkkalainen, Henri
A comprehensive literature review on E-Learning and OER in public administrations.•A contextualized Barrier Framework about core barriers in the public sector.•Lessons learned to improve implementation and adoption ...
Match: e-learning; Open Educational Resources

Influencing factors in OER usage of adult learners in Korea
Kim, Byoung Wook; Lee, Won Gyu; Lee, Byeong Rae; Shon, Jin Gon
Open Educational Resources (OER) is terminology that refers to educational resources (content and software) distributed through the Internet, free of charge and freely accessible, expanding learning opportunities for ...
Match: e-learning; Open Educational Resources

Building open educational resources from the ground up: South Africa's free high school science texts
Petrides, Lisa; Jimes, Cynthia
The relatively new field of open educational resources (OER) is just now receiving more widespread attention and study. As such, there have been few opportunities thus far to share knowledge across program, ...
Match: e-learning; Open Educational Resources

OER provision practices in context : a socio-technical study on OpenCourseWare initiatives in Spain
Villar Onrubia, Daniel
Based on the idea of broadening access to learning opportunities for all by means of new Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs), the Open Educational Resources (OER) movement has gained ground during the ...
Match: e-learning; Open Educational Resources

Open Educational Resources for management education lessons from experience
Humbert, Marc; Rébillard, Cécile; Rennard, Jean-Philippe
Open movements have gained increasing importance in various areas. In this paper we are interested in the particular case of Open Educational Resources (OER) and more specifically in the use of OER in Management ...
Match: e-learning; Open Educational Resources

New Pathways to Learning: Leveraging the Use of OERs to Support Non-formal Education
Olcott Jr, Don
The growth of non-formal education is expanding teaching and learning pathways for the delivery of global education. This growth, in concert with the expanded use of Open Educational Resources (OERs), is creating a ...
Match: e-learning; Open Educational Resources

Use of open educational resources at the UOC
Griset, Roger; Rivera López, José Manuel
The Open University of Catalonia (UOC: Universitat Oberta de Catalunya) is currently implementing its 2009-2014 Strategic Plan, which devotes an entire section to open educational resources. The working group on this ...
Match: e-learning; Open Educational Resources

Sharing and reuse in OER: Experiences gained from open reusable learning objects in health
Windle, Richard J.; Wharrad, Heather; McCormick, Damion; Laverty, Helen; Taylor, Michael G.
The open educational resource (OER) movement has the potential to have a truly transformative effect on higher education, but in order to do so it must move into the mainstream and facilitate widespread participation in ...
Match: evaluation; OER quality

Quali scenari per le pratiche e-learning nell’università? Gli “Open Educational Path”
Calvani, Antonio; Menichetti, Laura
E-learning for over fifteen years has evolved from a simple instrument for virtual educational interactions (1.0) to an environment capable of promoting wide participatory experiences (2.0). Recently, Open philosophy ...
Match: e-learning; Open Educational Resources