The OER Knowledge Cloud makes use of cookies. By continuing, you consent to this use. More information.
Student voice in textbook evaluation: Comparing OpStudent voice in textbook evaluation: Comparing open and restricted Textbooksen and Restricted Textbooks
Woodward, Scott · Lloyd, Adam · Kimmons, Royce

PublishedSeptember 2017
JournalThe International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning
Volume 18, Issue 6, Pages 150-163

Advocates for student voice in higher education believe students should have the right and power to engage in much of the decision-making traditionally dominated by instructors or administrators. This qualitative study examines the role of student voice in the evaluation of textbook quality. Evaluators included two graduate students enrolled in a project management course at a university in the western U.S. and their instructor. Evaluators used their own student-created metric to analyze the comparative quality of eight graduate-level project management textbooks, two of which were open and six copyright-restricted. The purposes of this study were to assess the comparative quality of low-cost open textbooks and traditional copyright-restricted textbooks and to identify key student-generated criteria wherein all textbooks may be improved to better serve student needs. The analysis revealed that textbooks can be rigorously and meaningfully evaluated by students, that open textbooks can compete with restricted textbooks in terms of quality, and that polyphonic approaches to textbook evaluation can be valuable for learning. We discuss the implications of open textbooks as viable, high-quality classroom options, and the importance of valuing both student voice and instructor perspectives to ensure the highest quality textbook selection for courses in higher education.

Keywords Open Educational Resources · open pedagogy · open textbooks

Published atAthabasca, AB
Other number6
Export optionsBibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar

3170-25030-1-PB%20(1).pdf · 498KB1 download

Viewed by 18 distinct readers


The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.

Click a star to be the first to rate this document


An Introduction to Open Education
Arts, Yvette; Call, Hannah; Cavan, Melissa; Holmes, Theresa P.; et al.
This open-access edited volume features chapters by leading and emerging authors and researchers in the field of open education and open educational resources. Sections include the foundations of OE and OER, current ...
Match: Kimmons, Royce; open pedagogy

Content is king: An analysis of how the twitter discourse surrounding open education unfolded from 2009 to 2016
Paskevicius, Michael; Veletsianos, George; Kimmons, Royce
Inspired by open educational resources, open pedagogy, and open source software, the openness movement in education has different meanings for different people. In this study, we use Twitter data to examine the ...
Match: Kimmons, Royce; Open Educational Resources; open pedagogy

Effects of open textbook adoption on teachers’ open practices
Mason, Stacie; Kimmons, Royce
The purpose of this qualitative study was to understand whether certain theoretical benefits that open educational resources (OER) might have on teacher practice were being realized by a group of secondary teachers ...
Match: Kimmons, Royce; Open Educational Resources

OER quality and adaptation in K-12: Comparing teacher evaluations of copyright-restricted, open, and open/adapted textbooks
Kimmons, Royce; McGreal, Rory; Conrad, Dianne
Conducted in conjunction with an institute on open textbook adaptation, this study compares textbook evaluations from practicing K-12 classroom teachers (n = 30) on three different types of textbooks utilized in their ...
Match: Kimmons, Royce; open textbooks

Open: The philosophy and practices that are revolutionizing education and science
Jhangiani, Rajiv; Biswas-Diener, Robert; Kwantlen Polytechnic University, CA; Noba Project
Affordable education. Transparent science. Accessible scholarship. These ideals are slowly becoming a reality thanks to the open education, open science, and open access movements. Running separate—if ...
Match: Open Educational Resources; open pedagogy; open textbooks

Ascertaining the relevance of Open Educational Resources by integrating various quality indicators
Sanz, Javier; Dodero, Juan Manuel; Sánchez, Salvador
The aim of the open educational resource (OER) development movement is to provide free access to high quality educational materials in repositories. However, having access to a large amount of educational materials does ...
Match: evaluation; Open Educational Resources

Repositories of open educational resources: An assessment of reuse and educational aspects
Santos-Hermosa, Gema; Ferran-Ferrer, Núria; Abadal, Ernest
This article provides an overview of the current state of repositories of open educational resources (ROER) in higher education at international level. It analyses a series of educational indicators to determine whether ...
Match: evaluation; Open Educational Resources

Teaching and learning without a textbook
Lin, Hong
Given the upsurge of textbook costs, college students increasingly expect universities and instructors to offer alternatives to traditional textbooks. One textbook alternative is using open educational resources (OER). ...
Match: Open Educational Resources; open pedagogy

What impacts do OER have on students? Students share their experiences with a health psychology OER at New York City College of Technology
Cooney, Cailean
This article reports findings from a study conducted with students in three sections of a Health Psychology course that replaced a traditional textbook with open educational resources (OER) as the primary course ...
Match: evaluation; Open Educational Resources

Degrees of Openness: The emergence of Open Educational Resources at the University of Cape Town
Hodgkinson-Williams, Cheryl; Gray, Eve
Information and communication technologies (ICTs) provide a range of opportunities to share educational materials and processes in ways that are not yet fully understood. In an extraordinary development, increasing ...
Match: Open Educational Resources; open pedagogy