Open educational resources as a tool for educational equity: Evidence from an introductory psychology class
Nusbaum, Amy T. · Cuttler, Carrie · Swindell, Samantha

Published9 January 2020
JournalFrontiers in Education
Volume 4, Issue 152, Pages 1-8
CountryUnited States, North America

ABSTRACT
A college education is becoming increasingly expensive, and the burden of this cost is often felt disproportionately by marginalized students. One aspect of rising college costs are textbook prices, which have increased at a rate that far surpasses inflation. Open educational resources (OER; free, openly-licensed course materials) are often proposed as a solution to this problem. It is not clear, however, whether these materials are equivalent in quality to standard commercial textbooks. During one semester, half of the Introductory Psychology sections at a large, public university were assigned to use OER while the other half were assigned to use the incumbent commercial textbook. Participants were asked to self-report the behaviors they engage in as a result of high textbook costs. We also examined student performance in the courses and students' perceptions and use of the two books. We found no significant differences between textbook groups on course performance or perceptions of the book, but marginalized students (first-generation students and/or ethnic minority students) reported engaging in negative behaviors (i.e., dropping a class) more often than their peers as a result of textbook costs. These findings suggest that textbook costs disproportionately affect our most vulnerable students and the use of OER may be one solution to this problem, particularly given the equivalent performance across textbook groups.

Keywords open educational resources · educational equity · introductory psychology · textbooks · marginalized students · college costs

LanguageEnglish
RefereedYes
RightsCC BY
DOI10.3389/feduc.2019.00152
URLhttps://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/feduc.2019.00152/full
Export optionsBibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar



AVAILABLE FILES
feduc-04-00152.pdf · 1MB3 downloads



Viewed by 191 distinct readers




CLOUD COMMUNITY REVIEWS

The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.

Click a star to be the first to rate this document


POST A COMMENT
SIMILAR RECORDS

Evaluating the effectiveness of adopting open educational resources in an introductory American government course
Lawrence, Christopher N.; Lester, Julie A.
In this article, we present findings from a grant-funded initiative to replace traditional, proprietary textbooks with an open content textbook under a Creative Commons license in the introductory American government ...
Match: introductory; textbooks; united states; north america

Who Gets to Wield Academic Mjolnir?: On Worthiness, Knowledge Curation, and Using the Power of the People to Diversify OER
Nusbaum, Amy T.
In many academic fields Western/white/male/cishetero/abled perspectives are often centered, while other perspectives are presented as “other.” Implicitly, this sends messages to students that success looks like one ...
Match: nusbaum, amy t.; united states; north america

United States: State department expands access to open educational resources in the Middle East and North Africa
Mena Report
The U.S. Department of State is sponsoring a special exchange program on Open Educational Resources (OER) for education leaders in the Middle East and North Africa. Open Educational Resources are ...
Match: united states; north america

The open road. Libraries, meet open textbooks.
Clobridge, Abby
The article reports on digital textbook options for students. It states that the print versions of textbooks are so expensive that its not affordable for students to buy them. It also mentions about the selection ...
Match: textbooks; united states; north america

RIPOFF 101: How the current practices of the textbook industry drive up the cost of college textbooks
Fairchild, Merriah; California Student Public Interest Research Group (CALPIRG)
With student and faculty complaints about the price of college textbooks on the rise, the California Student Public Interest Research Group (CALPIRG), the Oregon Student Public Interest Research Group (OSPIRG) and the ...
Match: textbooks; united states; north america

The promise of open access textbooks: A model for success
Henderson, Susie; Nelson, David
Can open textbooks provide a viable solution to the high cost of textbooks? Are open textbooks quality books? What will encourage faculty to develop or adopt open textbooks? What is a book? How do students prefer to ...
Match: textbooks; united states; north america

Academic Outcome Differences Between Community College Students Using Commercial Textbooks and Open Educational Resources
Lisa Lizabeth Schlegel
The purpose of this quantitative ex post facto comparative study was to assess the differences in final course grades between students enrolled in courses taught at a rural southwestern U.S. community college using ...
Match: educational equity; united states; north america

Substituting Open Educational Resources for Commercial Curriculum Materials: Effects on Student Mathematics Achievement in Elementary Schools
Hilton III, John; Larsen, Ross; Wiley, David; Fischer, Lane
Open Educational Resources (OER) have the potential to replace commercial learning materials in education. An empirical examination of this potential was conducted, comparing the end-of-year mathematics test results of ...
Match: textbooks; united states; north america

Academic Librarians Examination of University Students' and Faculty's Perceptions of Open Educational Resources
Fischer, Lane; Belikov, Olga; Ikahihifo, Tarah K.; Hilton III, John; et al.
A survey of 2,574 students and 1,157 faculty members across ten institutions of postsecondary education in the state of Utah was conducted by the Utah Academic Libraries Consortium. Survey items were created to ...
Match: textbooks; united states; north america

Open educational resources and the new classroom ecology
Blyth, Carl
Match: textbooks; united states; north america