The OER Knowledge Cloud makes use of cookies. By continuing, you consent to this use. More information.
Toward a critical approach for OER: A case study in removing the 'Big Five' from OER creation
Joseph, Kris · Guy, Julia · McNally, Michael B.

PublishedDecember 2019
JournalOpen Praxis
Volume 11, Issue 4, Pages 355-367
CountryCanada, North America

This paper examines the role of proprietary software in the production of open educational resources (OER). Using a single case study, the paper explores the implications of removing proprietary software from an OER project, with the aim of examining how complicated such a process is and whether removing such software meaningfully advances a critical approach to OER. The analysis reveals that software from the Big Five technology companies (Apple, Alphabet/Google, Amazon, Facebook and Microsoft) are deeply embedded in OER production and distribution, and that complete elimination of software or services from these companies is not feasible. The paper concludes by positing that simply rejecting Big Five technology introduces too many challenges to be justified on a pragmatic basis; however, it encourages OER creators to remain critical in their use of technology and continue to try to advance a critical approach to OER.

Keywords open source software · proprietary software · critical approaches to open educational resources · critical theory

RightsCC BY-SA
Export optionsBibTex · EndNote · Tagged XML · Google Scholar

1020-3976-2-PB.pdf · 149.6KB

Viewed by 26 distinct readers


The evaluations below represent the judgements of our readers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Cloud editors.

Click a star to be the first to rate this document


Critical spaces for critical times: Global conversations in literacy research as an open professional development and practices resource
Albers, Peggy; Cho, Ram A.; Shin, Ji Hye; Pang, Myoung Eun; et al.
This paper reflects an OER (Open Educational Resources) critical literacy project, Global Conversations in Literacy Research (GCLR), (, now in its fourth year. GCLR ...
Match: critical

A misapplication of MOOCs: Critical pedagogy writ massive
Morris, Sean Michael
On November 21 at the OpenEd Conference in Washington, DC, Sean Michael Morris and Jesse Stommel will present on critical digital pedagogy and MOOCs. This is the second of three articles that inspired that talk. The ...
Match: critical

OER as online edutainment resources: A critical look at open content, branded content, and how both affect the OER movement
Moe, Rolin
Despite a rise in awareness and production of open education resources (OER) over the past decade, mainstream media outlets continue to define open in economic terms of consumer cost and not in theoretical terms of ...
Match: critical; critical theory

Dimensions of open research: Critical reflections on openness in the ROER4D project
King, Thomas; Hodgkinson-Williams, Cheryl-Ann; Willmers, Michelle; Walji, Sukaina
Open Research has the potential to advance the scientific process by improving the transparency, rigour, scope and reach of research, but choosing to experiment with Open Research carries with it a set of ideological, ...
Match: critical

Exploring the role of assessment in developing learners' critical thinking in Massive Open Online Courses
Zhao, Catherine; Bhalla, Sonal; Halliday, Lesley; Travaglia, Joanne; et al.
Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) have provided learners unprecedented opportunities to access university level education. As a form of largely free and self-paced education, MOOCs are less formal than credit-bearing ...
Match: critical

Turning the tide: a socio-critical model and framework for improving student success in open distance learning at the University of South Africa
Subotzky, George; Prinsloo, Paul
The article presents a socio-critical model and framework for understanding, predicting, and enhancing student success developed at the University of South Africa. An extensive literature review indicated that ...
Match: critical

If Freire made a MOOC: Open education as resistance
Morris, Sean Michael; Stommel, Jesse
On November 21 at the OpenEd Conference in Washington, DC, Sean Michael Morris and Jesse Stommel will present on critical digital pedagogy and MOOCs. This is the second of three articles that inspired that talk. The ...

Changing our (dis)course: A distinctive social justice aligned definition of Open Education
Lambert, Sarah
This paper investigates the degree to which recent digital Open Education literature is aligned to social justice principles, starting with the first UNESCO definition of Open Educational Resources (OER). A critical ...
Match: critical theory

From EDUPUNK to open policy: Critical technology Praxis within higher education
Miller, Jamison
Emerging less than a decade ago, the term EDUPUNK sought to encapsulate the nascent rebellion against the corporatism and neoliberal ideology permeating digital aspects of higher education. A loose association of ...
Match: critical; North America

Peer-to-peer recognition of learning in open education
Schmidt, Jan Philipp; Geith, Christine; HĂ„klev, Stian; Thierstein, Joel
Recognition in education is the acknowledgment of learning achievements. Accreditation is certification of such recognition by an institution, an organization, a government, a community, etc. There are a number of ...
Match: open source software; Canada